When business leaders talk about workplace flexibility, the conversation almost always turns to remote and hybrid work. But what about employees who can't work from home?
You may have production workers who need to be on the manufacturing floor covering 24 hours, warehouse employees whose shift starts at 6 a.m., or a construction crew that needs to be at a jobsite within a certain timeframe.
And what about your accounting team, salespeople, and managers who may have more options for where and when they work? They're all part of the same organization. But their jobs, responsibilities, and needs can be very different.
We often talk about workplace flexibility in blanket statements as though it means the same thing to everyone.
For growing businesses, this is more than a question about employee preferences. It's about developing workplace practices that help attract and retain good employees while keeping the business running effectively. And that requires looking beyond where people work.
Flexibility Means Different Things to Different Employees
For someone working in an office, flexibility might mean working from home two days a week or adjusting their schedule around an appointment. For someone working on a production line, it might mean knowing their schedule further in advance, having input into shift assignments, or being able to trade shifts when something unexpected comes up. For a field employee, it might mean more predictable start times or a little more notice when assignments change.
None of these employees necessarily value flexibility less, but they may have different opportunities to experience it. And that's an important distinction for employers.
If your organization has decided that flexibility isn't possible because many of your employees need to be onsite or you want them in the office, you may be overlooking options that could make a meaningful difference in their working lives.
Flexibility doesn't have to mean working from anywhere. Sometimes it means having more predictability, more input, or more control over the parts of a job that can reasonably accommodate it.
Start With What Your Business Can Support
Of course, operational requirements matter. A manufacturer can't leave a production line understaffed. A distribution center needs adequate coverage to fulfill orders. A construction company needs crews onsite when work is scheduled. But within those requirements, there may be more room for flexibility than you think.
Consider a few possibilities:
- More predictable schedules: Can employees receive their schedules further in advance so they can better plan childcare, appointments, and other responsibilities?
- Shift-swapping options: Could employees exchange shifts within established guidelines without creating staffing or overtime problems?
- Greater input into scheduling: Could employees express preferences for shifts or schedules, even if those preferences can't always be accommodated?
- More thoughtful overtime practices: When additional hours are necessary, can employees receive more advance notice or have opportunities to volunteer before overtime is assigned?
- Cross-training: Could developing employees to perform multiple roles give managers more coverage options while creating greater scheduling flexibility?
-
Not every option will work for every organization. The point isn't to promise flexibility you can't deliver. It's to look for opportunities within the realities of how your business operates.
And some of those opportunities may be relatively inexpensive compared with the cost of repeatedly recruiting and training replacement employees.
Don't Make Assumptions
If leadership decides that employees would appreciate a particular benefit and invests time and money in providing it, they may discover it wasn't what employees valued most after all. Maybe employees would rather have more predictable schedules than an additional workplace perk. Maybe they're looking for more opportunities to develop skills and move into better-paying roles.
The best way to understand what matters to your workforce is to ask, and the questions don't have to be complicated.
- What's the most difficult part of managing your schedule outside of work?
- What changes would make your workday easier?
- Are there scheduling or work arrangements that would help you without affecting your ability to do your job?
You won't be able to accommodate every request. But you may discover opportunities that haven't occurred to leadership because the people making those decisions experience work very differently.
There's another benefit to asking: Employees can often identify practical solutions that managers and executives haven't considered. The people doing the work every day may have valuable ideas about how to make that work more manageable.
Consistency Matters More Than Uniformity
This becomes particularly important for organizations with both onsite and office-based employees. Even though your accounting team may be able to work remotely occasionally, while your production employees can't, it doesn't automatically mean your workplace practices are inequitable. Employees understand that different jobs have different requirements.
What can create frustration is when those differences seem arbitrary, poorly explained, or disproportionately favorable to certain groups. That's why it's important to establish clear principles for how flexibility decisions are made, even when the arrangements themselves differ.
For example, your organization might commit to:
- Considering flexibility requests based on legitimate job requirements and operational needs.
- Giving employees reasonable input into schedules and working arrangements wherever practical.
- Applying decisions consistently across employees in comparable roles.
- Explaining why certain arrangements are available for some positions but not others.
- Reviewing policies periodically as business needs and employee expectations change.
These principles create a more consistent employee experience without requiring every employee to have the same working arrangement.
The goal isn't to offer everyone identical flexibility. It's to make thoughtful, consistent decisions that respect employees while supporting the needs of the business
Flexibility Has to Work for the Business Too
There's another side to this conversation that shouldn't get lost. Flexibility that creates chronic understaffing, increases costs beyond what the business can sustain, or continually shifts burdens onto other employees isn't a good long-term solution.
That's why managers need to be part of developing and implementing these practices. They understand the operational requirements, coverage challenges, and daily realities that may not be obvious to leadership. They also need clear guidelines so employees aren't receiving entirely different answers depending on which supervisor they ask.
Before implementing a change, consider:
- Can we maintain the coverage and productivity we need?
- Will the arrangement create additional costs or compliance concerns?
- Can managers administer it consistently?
- Will it create unintended burdens for other employees?
- How will we know whether it's working?
You might start with a limited pilot, evaluate the results, and make adjustments before expanding the practice. That gives the organization a way to determine whether the change delivers value without committing to something it may not be able to sustain.
It's also important to make sure new practices comply with applicable wage and hour laws, leave requirements, and other employment obligations.
Flexibility should make managing your workforce easier, not create new problems
The Real Opportunity is Understanding Your Workforce
For growing businesses, competing for talent can be challenging.
You may not be able to offer the remote work arrangements available in other industries. And you may not have the budget to outspend every competitor on compensation and benefits. But that doesn't mean you have nothing else to offer. A predictable schedule can have real value to someone managing family responsibilities. A manager who works with employees to accommodate reasonable needs can make a workplace more attractive. Opportunities to develop skills, gain more responsibility, and advance can give employees reasons to build their future with your organization. And clear, consistently applied policies can help employees understand what to expect, even when different roles require different arrangements.
None of those things requires turning an onsite job into a remote one. It requires understanding what matters to your employees, identifying what your business can reasonably support, and making intentional decisions about how the two fit together.
Your employees don't all do the same work. Their flexibility doesn't have to look the same, either.
The conversation worth having isn't how your business can offer flexibility the way another employer does. It's what flexibility could look like for your own workforce.
If you want to build workplace practices that work for your people and your business, we can help. Let's have a conversation.
